Ottawa Decisions


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Derakhshan v Narula (2017 ONSC 3738)
motion — security for costs — fees — tabs — printing
Justice L. Sheard

McEachran v Di Tommaso (2017 ONSC 3603)
income — child support — expenses — spouse — gymnastics
Justice T. Engelking

Akimov v Makhnatch (2017 ONSC 3528)
child support — arrears — offer to settle — successful — costs
Justice A. Doyle

Deslauriers v Pommainville (2017 ONSC 3162)
child support — father — income — table amount — expenses
Justice A. Doyle

Djediga c. Bouchebaba (2017 CanLII 34366)
motion — dépens — emploi — gain — voyager
Juge A. Doyle

Casselman v Noonan (2017 ONSC 3415)
unsupervised access — children — sole custody — depression — supervised access
Justice S. Kershman

Bouchard v Poulin (2017 ONSC 3328)
matrimonial home — agreement — contract — settlement — séparation
Justice M. Shelston

Civil Matters

ARPA Canada and Patricia Maloney v R. (2017 ONSC 3285)
provision of abortion services — statistical information — hospitals — records — meaningful
Justice M. Labrosse

Saghbini et al. v Gabbat (2017 ONSC 3607)
children — pre-judgment interest — settlement — behalf of the infant — companionship
Justice S. Corthorn

El-Hawary v Tam (2017 ONSC 3549)
disbursements — costs thrown away — substantial indemnity basis — adjournment — inclusive
Justice L. Ratushny

Whalen v Bismil (2017 ONSC 3540)
treatment — appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences — mental disorder — lack of insight — mood stabilizers
Justice S. Corthorn

Kaymar Rehabilitation Inc. v Champlain Community Care Access Center (2017 ONSC 3504)
costs on a substantial indemnity — substantial indemnity basis — exact measure of the actual — settle — amount
Justice J. Parfett

Farley Manufacturing Inc. v Oz Optics Ltd. (2017 ONSC 3321)
inspection — fabric — experts — alleged deficiencies — mediation
Justice R. Ryan Bell

Korolew v Canadian Union of Public Employees (2017 ONSC 3474)
waives — employment — statements — hereinafter collectively referred — photocopied
Justice R. Beaudoin

Cooney Bulk Sales Limited v Teamsters Local Union No. 91 (2017 ONSC 3471)
costs — partial indemnity basis — lengthened — claimed — proportionality
Justice R. Smith

Heyde v Theberge Developments Limited (2017 ONSC 3462)
costs — certification motion — awarded — success — indemnity
Justice R. Smith

Verner (Re) (2017 ONSC 3406)
posting loan — bankruptcy — surplus income — opposing creditor — lender
Justice S. Kershman

Scaffidi-Argentina v Tega Homes Developments Inc. (2017 ONSC 3427)
prejudgment interest — partial indemnity costs — damages — lost rental income — cost of rebuilding
Justice L. Sheard

Divisional Court Decisions from Ottawa Judges

Agboola v Unoh (2017 ONSC 3572)
acquiesced to the child remaining — reconciliation — email — wronged parent — application
Justices T. Lederer, J. Trimble, and L. Sheard

Norris v Norris (2017 ONSC 3515)
motion — vacating — costs — relief — amendment
Justice R. Beaudoin

168774 Ontario Inc. v Registrar of Alcohol and Gaming (2017 ONSC 3579)
evidence — server — alcohol — consumed — sanction
Justices W. Matheson, J. Trimble, and L. Sheard

Free v County of Norfolk et al. (2017 ONSC 3571)
drainage works — owner — factum — adjournment — standing
Justices W. Matheson, J. Trimble, and L. Sheard


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Elmoukousi v Marine (2017 ONSC 3033)
father — child — lawyer — legal aid — visits
Justice A. Doyle

Campbell v Lapierre (2017 ONSC 3017)
offer to settle — costs — father — children — parenting
Justice A. Doyle

Baker v Baker (2017 ONSC 3266)
spousal support — income — severance — unequalized pension — representing the mid-range
Justice T. Engelking

Lundy v Lundy (2017 ONSC 3224)
motion — offer to settle — indemnity — costs — estate
Justice L. Sheard

Uriu v Rivadeneyra (2017 ONSC 3180)
costs awarded — payable — motion — outcome — determined
Justice L. Sheard

Morey v Bisson (2017 ONSC 1688)
costs — children — amount — lives — offer
Justice M. Labrosse

Civil Matters

Kuhnle v Fisher (2017 ONSC 3336)
costs — property — easement — occasional — indemnity
Justice T. Ray

Verner (Re) (2017 ONSC 3406)
posting loan — bankruptcy — surplus income — opposing creditor — lender
Justice S. Kershman

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Melis v Zwanenburg (2017 ONSC 2847)
insurance — support — payor — collateral mortgage — estate
Justice R. Beaudoin

Akimov v Markhnatch (2017 ONSC 2860)
income — child support — arrears — father — payor
Justice A. Doyle

Luckman v Luckman (2017 ONSC 2800)
child support — income — atrial fibrillation — access — children
Justice M. Shelston

St-Pierre c. Bélisle (2017 ONCS 2889)
intimées — offres — échelle d indemnité — dépens — litige
Juge M. Labrosse

Civil Matters

Kuhnle v Fisher (2017 ONSC 2905)
property — right-of-way — easement — parcel — access
Justice T. Ray

Carby-Samuels II v Carby-Samuels (2017 ONSC 2911)
arguments — attenuated process — copy — dismissal — requisition
Justice R. Beaudoin

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Gauthier v Gauthier (2017 ONSC 2781)
spousal support — child support — income — material change of circumstances — variation
Justice A. Doyle

McCarthy v Labonté (2017 ONSC 2775)
costs — offers — cross-motion for summary — offer to settle — motions
Justice M. Labrosse

Syed v Syed (2017 ONSC 2588)
husband — wife — income — non-dissipation — equalization payment
Justice A. Doyle

Clermont v Addie (2017 ONSC 2643)
representing a top-up for child — costs — top-up for child support payments — offer — successful
Justice T. Engelking

Civil Matters

Wallace. v Campbell (2017 ONSC 2767)
motion — costs outline — materials — indemnity — properties
Justice R. Beaudoin

Cahill v Cahill (2017 ONSC 2707)
passing of accounts — removing as the sole trustee — respect — conference — additional costs
Justice S. Corthorn

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Himyary v Al-Yasiri (2017 ONSC 2340)
costs — father — motion — offers to settle — custody
Justice L. Sheard

Alwan v Aulaiwi (2017 ONSC 2309)
motion — third-party record holders — extend the time — leave — third-party disclosure
Justice R. Beaudoin

Children’s Aid Society of Ottawa v M.L. (2017 ONSC 2284)
child — care — father — home — paternal
Justice M. Shelston

Verhey v Verhey (2017 ONSC 2216)
spousal support — income — postsecondary — tuition — child support
Justice M. Shelston

Lundy v Lundy (2017 ONSC 2101)
co-estate trustee — estate — equalization — surviving spouse — incurred in good faith
Justice L. Sheard

Lockman v Rancourt (2017 ONSC 2274)
arbitration — peremptory — email — request for an adjournment — lawyer
Justice T. Engelking

Szonyi v Szonyi (2017 ONSC 2171)
procedural motion — substantial indemnity — endorsement — minutes of settlement — costs
Justice S. Corthorn

Civil Matters

Ramsarran v Assaly Asset Management Corporation (2017 ONSC 2394)
resort to the attenuated process — pleading — requisition — apparent on the face — vexatious
Justice R. Beaudoin

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Campbell v Campbell (2017 ONSC 2139)
estate — will — bifurcation — application — rules
Justice C. MacLeod

Szonyi v Szonyi (2017 ONSC 2171)
procedural motion — substantial indemnity — endorsement — minutes of settlement — costs
Justice S. Corthorn

Boyer v Brown (2017 ONSC 2047)
child support — costs — motion — arrears — offer
Justice L. Sheard

Derakhshan v Narula (2017 ONSC 1996)
motions — costs — time spent — summonses — hours
Justice L. Sheard

Derakhshan v Narula (2017 ONSC 1999)
motions — hours — spent — time — bad faith
Justice L. Sheard

Derakhshan v Narula (2017 ONSC 2053)
enough assets in to pay — motion — security for costs — waste of time — nuisance
Justice L. Sheard

Arnold v Deere (2017 ONSC 1936)
disclosure — orders — justly — finds — uncontested
Justice S. Kershman

Uriu v Rivadeneyra (2017 ONSC 1930)
costs — motion — return — parenting — awarded
Justice L. Sheard

Civil Matters

Farley v Ottawa (Police Services Board) (2017 ONSC 2197)
partial indemnity — costs of the motion — allinclusive — fees incurred — mathematical
Justice C. MacLeod

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Campbell v Lapierre (2017 ONSC 1645)
father — children s best interests — parents — joint custody — school
Justice A. Doyle

Fortier c. Lauzon (2017 CanLII 13618)
transfert du foyer conjugal — question des dépens — gain — représente lui-même — outrage
Juge M. Labrosse

Stacey v Stacey (2017 ONSC 1226)
father — children — costs — legal fees — flight
Justice M. Shelston

Astley v Labelle (2017 ONSC 1378)
costs — offer to settle — motion — bad faith — spent
Justice L. Sheard

Bédard v Crawford (2017 ONSC 1679)
disclosure — motion — ending — cross-motion requesting — statements
Justice T. Engelking

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Bloom v Bloom (2017 ONSC 1568)
children — father — status quo — will — matrimonial home
Justice A. Doyle

Aden v Mohamud (2017 ONSC 1629)
spousal support — agencies — marriage — income — trips
Justice T. Engelking

Dieng c Seck (2017 ONCS 1479)
séparation — aliments — divorce — contrat familial — entente
Juge P. Roger

Gill v Dhillon (2017 ONSC 1565)
child support — income — spousal support — daycare — pay
Justice T. Engelking

Dallaire c Brunet (2017 ONSC 1564)
motion — aliments — dépens intégrals à compter — offre — reflète
Juge P. Roger

Mccafferty v St.Jean (2017 ONSC 1431)
litigation — offers to settle — financial disclosure — costs — speedy
Justice M. Linhares de Sousa

Continue Reading…


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Birkett v Love (2017 ONSC 1231)
income — offers to settle — costs — support — motion
Justice A. Doyle

Shouldice v Shouldice (2017 ONSC 1045)
offer — spousal support — parenting — settlement — child support
Justice J. Mackinnon

Pitre v Lalande (2017 ONSC 1043)
post-secondary education — substantial indemnity — motion — dental expenses — offers
Justice S. Corthorn

Civil Matters

Canadian Council of the Blind v Burt (2017 ONSC 1135)
national office — e-mail — governance — defamatory — leave to amend
Justice M. Labrosse

Scarf et al. and Ottawa Athletic Club (2016 ONSC 7968)
proposed — reformulation — negligent misrepresentation — motion — fresh
Justice R. Pelletier

Scharf et al. v. Ottawa Athletic Club Inc. et al. (2016 CanLII 95644)
carrying on business — summary judgment motion — costs — succeeded — presumptively
Justice R. Pelletier

Criminal Matters

R. c. Faucher (2017 ONSC 913)
peine d emprisonnement avec sursis — attentat à la pudeur — victimes — couronne — délinquant
Juge P. Roger

Court of Appeal Decisions of Local Interest

R. v. Cameron (2017 ONCA 150)
dissociative state — defence expert — jury — killed his daughter-in-law — automatism
Justices D/ Doherty, J. Laskin, and L. Roberts

Sennek v. Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 116 (2017 ONCA 154)
interlocutory — perfect — litigation guardian — sanction for non-compliance — extension
Justice G. Pardu

R. v. R.S. (2017 ONCA 141)
pre-sentence custody — sentence — victim — pre-conviction custody — offence
Justices J. MacPherson, P. Rouleau, and D. Brown

R. v. L.F.P. (2017 ONCA 132)
preliminary inquiry — victim — offence — count — published in any document
Justices A. Hoy, D. Doherty, and B. Miller


Recently Published Ottawa Decisions 2

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Leedy v Leedy (2017 ONSC 868)
temporary spousal support — access — unwise — generous — ordered
Justice C. Hackland

Smith v McQuinn (2017 ONSC 859)
costs — offer to settle — motion — post-secondary educational expenses — support
Justice A. Doyle

Verhey v Verhey (2017 ONSC 837)
jurisdiction to vary — post-secondary education — married — agreement — separation
Justice M. Shelston

Wood v Evans (2017 ONSC 891)
mental health — child support — costs orders — private investigator — meritless
Justice T. Ray

Melis v Zwanenburg (2017 ONSC 613)
payee spouse — income — equalization — pension — double recovery
Justice R. Beaudoin

Civil Matters

Mannion Heating & Plumbing, Strang and Strang Management, v, Bam Industries and Bruce Minty Ltd. (2017 ONSC 934)
clients — entitled to accept unsolicited work — injunction — solicitation — enjoins
Justice M. Labrosse

McLeish v Daines (2017 ONSC 903)
jury — correcting instruction — analogy — police officer — cash grab
Justice R. Smith

Continue Reading…