Summary of the Legislative Research Webinar

Legislative history and intent is very useful for legal research. Canadian jurisprudence places a lot of importance on the intent of the legislators when they were creating legislation, so the debates are used to do so.  

Legislative history: tracing an act, section, subsection or term to the first instance, a specific point in time or to see how it evolved over time.

Legislative Intent: finding the relevant debates, committee proceedings and other documents related to the Act, section, subsection or term your are looking into.

To provide legislative intent, you need to do a legislative history first. Doing that will show you where to look for debates; you’ll have the year, parliament and session, the bill number, etc. and it will be a time saver. 

Before you start, you need to  

  • Define your research question: 
    • What are you looking for? What do you need to know? (act, section or subsection, term) 
    • How far back do you need to go or what period of time are you looking into? 
  • Create a document to keep track of your research!

 

Federal Legislative Research (all resources and their links are listed at the end of each section)

History

The example for the session was s. 320.14 of the Criminal Code, which is operating a vehicle while impaired. To do legislative history, you need to trace back the consolidations and amendments, here’s how I did it for this example:

For recent amendments, you can use the Table of Public Statutes (TOPS):

It will show you the amendments made to every section. It’s not a complete list, but if you only need the amendments, that’s the place to start.  

There’s also the Justice Laws Website:

If you go to the section you are looking into, you’ll find the latest amendments at the end of the section. In this case – 2018, c. 21, s.15.

You can browse older versions of it using the “Previous Versions” button at the top. 

If we select a version before the enactment in 2018, we see that the previous section was repealed. It’s mentioned under s. 320.26 or you can use ctrl+ f to find the section “Operation while impaired”. Once you find the previous version, you find more amendments and consolidations:

To find the older amendments, you can use HeinOnline. There are three databases for Canadian statutes:

To find a consolidation, you would use the last one.

  • R.S., 1985, c. C-46, s. 253 (p. 159)

 

You can see that it’s not the right section in the citation (253 vs 250), mistakes can happen. For this one I just browsed back a few pages, but you could also do a keyword search if that happens. You can then find the previous amendments and consolidations to continue your research. I’ll again skip a few citations and go directly to R.S., c. C-34, s. 234.

  • R.S., c. C-34, s. 234 (p. 1615)

This citation is for another consolidation. When you don’t have the date after R.S. it simply means the previous one (in this case 1970). You would again find the right chapter and the right page, to find the previous amendment.

  • 1968-69, c. 38, s. 16 (p. 880)

For an annual statute, you need to use the Acts of the Parliament of Canada database on HeinOnline. It’s organized by date

In older statutes, the amendments where on the side of the page. 

To go back to the first instance of this section, we would continue the same process until 1921. If you don’t know the citation, you can use the Table of Contents. 

  • 1921, c. 25, 285C (p. 122) 

The first image is the Table of Contents, the first number on the left is the chapter, and the other one the page number.

The second image is the first page of chapter 25, you can see the title of the Act and the date it received Royal Assent. There are no more amendments for this section. but as you can see on the second image, there are additional ones for the Criminal Code related to other sections.

To make sure you’ve covered everything, you can do a keyword search on the main page of the database. As you saw citations can contain mistakes or be forgotten. And of course, here I’ve skipped a few amendments, because it would’ve taken too much time, but for this type of research you want to look at all of them to get the full picture. 

Intent

To find recent debates we would go to LegisInfo. The first thing you need is find the bill number.  

Going back to the latest amendment –

  • 2018, c. 21, s. 15.

An easy way to find this information is to check the date the Act received royal assent and the title. This information is also sometimes included in the Annual Statutes’ Table of Contents, you can also look in Debates Indices or Journals.

The first image is the first page of the Act on HeinOnline. The second image is my search on LegisInfo, I did a keyword search (conveyances) and selected the 42nd Parliament, 1st session (for 2018). The first result at the top is the Bill I was looking for – C-46. You can validate that with the title and the Royal Assent date.

On LegisInfo, you have all the debates from the Senate and House of Commons and the committee proceedings. For recent bills it is quite easy. You also have more documents under the tab about, like a legislative summary, press releases, background information and other publications. Not all the bills have all these additional documents. And you don’t always have links, so you’ll have to do additional research to find what you want from there. 

Another tool you can use is “Search the debates” on the House of Commons website. If you are looking into a specific term and you don’t want to go through all the debates.  

You can add filters to your search to find exactly what you’re looking for. Here, I selected the Parliament and session, I added topics and you can also do a keyword search on top of that to narrow your results. If you want to look into committee proceedings, it’s under the tab committee and it looks exactly the same. 

If your amendment is between the 35th and 36th parliament. They are listed on LegisInfo, but if you click on one, there won’t be any details. Instead, you want to go on the House of Commons website, and to House Publications. Click on the date to select the right Parliament and session, and you will get the debates. You need to use the Index to find the relevant debates.

Going back to our example, I want debates from 1921 – we need to go into Parliamentary Historical Resources.  

Some debates are not translated, and the committee’s proceedings are not all there. So, if you can’t find yours, it means you have to look for a print version. Some are available at the University of Ottawa library, you can search in omni with the name of the committee before going in person. For the 1921 debates, it’s under the 13th Parliament, 5th session.

If there is an Index, start there, for some years it’s a separate volume. For this example, it’s at the end of every volume.  It’s organized by alphabetical order, and I did a keyword search with “Criminal Code”. If you’re confident that the subject you’re looking into is going to be in Index you can use a more precise keyword. In later indices, all the Bills with their number are listed under “Bills”, which makes it easier. In this example, we can see that our topic was discussed at page 3911, which is in volume 4. 

You can then download the page to PDF and then you can also copy the text – just double check for mistakes.  

If you don’t find anything with the keywords you’ve used, try other keywords and if you can’t find anything, that’s possible. Sometimes there are no debates on a specific section. And if you want to link to this document, use the persistent URL at the bottom and take note of the image number.  

Note that for consolidations, if there isn’t an amendment, there won’t be any debates because they were just republishing the act for convenience.  

Resources

Ontario Legislative Research

History

For this second example, I will use the Education Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.2, s. 8 (1), ss. 26. To find recent amendments, you can use the e-laws website.

Your first option is to use the Table of Public Statutes. It is a list of Ontario’s consolidated and unconsolidated public statutes. It indicates whether the statute is on e-Laws or not, the amendments, if the statute was repealed, and more. It is a really great tool to start your research. The only thing is you won’t know the amendment is for which section.

Another option is you can go directly into the Act itself on e-laws. At the top you have access to the previous versions and the legislative history. 

If you want to find the older amendments and consolidations, you can use HeinOnline and it works the same as for the federal legislation. Only difference is you need to go into the Provincial Statutes of Canada database and select Ontario. First, you have the Annual Statutes from 1967 to 1987, then, you have older ones from the Province of Upper Canada from 1792 to 1831, and the rest is the consolidations.

  • R.S.O. 1990, c. E.2, s. 8 (1), ss. 26 (p. 516)

You can see the previous amendment at the end of the section. If you want to go further back in your research you would just continue to follow the breadcrumbs until you find what it is you were looking for.  

Intent

For the debates, you can use the Legislative Assembly of Ontario website. To find the Bill number, they are sometimes included in the Table of Contents of the Annual Statutes, or you can browse the Bills on OLA, it goes back to 1995. 

If we are looking for the committee debates (42nd Parliament to now) – you can find them on the Legislative business page, under Committees. If you are looking for the debates, you need to click on House documents, then Hansard Search (1974 to now). 

You can then select the right Parliament and session and add filters and keywords to your search to narrow the results.

Resources

 

Finding relevant caselaw

  • Looking at Annotated Acts

We have a lot at the library, and you might have some at your office. They will contain caselaw that were relevant at the time of printing. So, if you take an older version, it will be a snapshot of that period of time. 

  •  Noting up by section number  

First way to do it is on CanlII. You can use the third search box, the Noteup/Discussion box. It will allow you to see the documents that cite a specific piece of legislation and you can add one or more sections or subsections to your search. Don’t forget to switch the “or” to “and” if you want cases about both. You can narrow your results with the date filter, if you are looking for older decisions or use keywords.

You can also do that on Westlaw.  One way to do it is by searching with your citation: “R.S.C. 1985, c. C-46, s. 320”, and you will find it under “Statutes and Regulations”. If you click on the section, you will have citing references at the top and you can choose Cases and Decisions. You even have secondary sources listed and you can filter the results with the box on the left. You also have direct links to annotations. 

Just a note that this can be challenging if the section no longer exists. For recent amendments that works great. And for both CanLII and Westlaw you can search the provincial legislation as well.  

  • Phrase searching. So, if you have specific wording, you can try searching for those specific words in quotation marks or
  • Use other Boolean operators

“title of the Act” /s section # – to search for both terms in the same sentence (Ex. “Criminal Code” /s 320)

OR

“title of the Act” /number of words section # – to search for both terms within a number of words (Ex. “Criminal Code” /5 320)

 

 

Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Baillargeon v. Nesbitt (2026 ONSC 6167)
In a family law application, the court dismissed a request to set aside a cohabitation agreement. It found no failure to disclose significant assets or liabilities and no proven lack of understanding of the agreement’s nature or consequences. Not reading the agreement did not justify relief. The agreement remained valid.
Justice T. Engelking

Civil Matters

Azzi v. Kelly (2026 ONSC 6093)
On a motion for leave to rely on a late-served supplementary expert report, the judge applied a contextual r. 53.08 analysis guided by the interests of justice. Because the one-page report introduced no new opinions and caused no compensable prejudice or delay, leave was granted.
Justice A. Kaufman

Gulzar v. Pioneer Mews Inc. et al (2026 ONSC 6049)
On a motion to strike or dismiss, the Court holds that absolute privilege for statements and documents in judicial proceedings extends to the lawyer’s client. The plaintiff’s tort and rights-based claims against the defendant arise from allegedly false evidence filed in prior litigation and are struck as frivolous, vexatious, and an abuse of process, with $3,000 costs awarded.
Justice A. Doyle

Metro Taxi Ltd. et al. v. City of Ottawa (2026 ONSC 6030)
In a class proceeding on aggregate damages, the Court refuses to strike the plaintiffs’ expert report, finding “de facto expropriation” language described economic effects rather than a new cause of action. Applying s. 24 of the Class Proceedings Act, 1992 and the Ramdath factors, it holds aggregate damages are appropriate.
Justice M. Smith

Criminal Matters

R. v. Mohamed (2026 ONSC 5981)
In sentencing proceedings for arson with disregard for human life causing bodily harm alongside a first-degree murder conviction, the judge applied the three-step multiple-offence framework but focused on setting fit sentences for each arson count. Schizophrenia and related factors mitigated moral culpability, but public protection and prior similar arson aggravated. The offender received 20 years concurrent, plus ancillary orders.
Justice A. London-Weinstein

R. v. R.A.H. (2026 ONSC 3398)
In a criminal application for witness-protection measures, the judge granted non-disclosure and publication-ban orders and allowed four covert CSIS agents to testify by videoconference behind a screen, without visual identification. Applying the Dagenais/Mentuck and N.S. balancing, the judge found compelling national security and safety risks, peripheral continuity evidence, no adequate alternatives, and minimal impact on trial fairness.
Justice K. McVey

R. v. R.A.H. (2026 ONSC 5592)
In a criminal trial for terrorism offences, the judge finds the accused guilty of conspiracy to commit murder for a terrorist group and of facilitating terrorist activity by attempting to acquire a firearm, based on sustained, detailed efforts to obtain weapons for a planned mass-casualty attack. He is acquitted of facilitation through propaganda-sharing.
Justice K. McVey

R. v. R-L (2026 ONSC 5920)
In criminal sentencing following a guilty plea to sexual assault, the judge held that denunciation and general deterrence required a penitentiary term because the offender abused a position of trust, provided drugs and alcohol, and involved another adult in sexual activity with a 15-year-old. Despite strong rehabilitation evidence and significant collateral consequences, a four-year sentence and ancillary orders were imposed.
Justice A. London-Weinstein

Divisional Court Decisions by Ottawa Judges or of Local Interest

Clegg v. Carleton Condo Corporation, (2026 ONSC 3094)
On an appeal from a Tribunal decision, the Court dismisses claims that a condominium corporation unlawfully disclosed a unit owner’s name in board minutes and a periodic information certificate. It holds the references concerned litigation, not “records relating to specific units or owners”, and upholds a costs award, ordering $10,000.
Justices J. McCarthy, H. McGee, and S. Shore

Maggi v. Smith (2026 ONSC 6080)
In an appeal from a Small Claims defamation judgment, the Court dismisses a motion for fresh evidence under the Palmer test and upholds liability for an X post alleging a public figure personally threatened voters’ permanent resident status. It finds justification unproven and no reviewable error regarding freedom of expression or responsible communication. The appeal is dismissed.
Justice K. Jensen

Zandi v. Normar Drywall Inc. (2026 ONSC 6149)
In a Small Claims Court appeal, the Court dismisses a debtor’s challenge to judgment for an unpaid invoice balance. It holds there was no procedural unfairness in refusing an adjournment. Even if discoverability was arguable, written texts disputing the amount still acknowledged liability under s. 13, keeping the claim timely.
Justice K. Jensen

Court of Appeal Decisions of Local Interest

Abada v. University of Ottawa (2026 ONCA 760)
In an appeal from a trial judgment dismissing a civil action, the Court rejects challenges to findings that the supervisor did not impose menial tasks, withhold bursaries, or prevent a comprehensive exam. It upholds credibility-based findings and the trial judge’s refusal to recall a witness, and dismisses the appeal with fixed costs.
Justices P. Rouleau, S.Coroza and, P. Osborne

Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Jeannine Côté c. Réjean Faubert (2026 ONCS 5639)
Dans une motion pour jugement sommaire en droit de la famille, le Tribunal reconnaît le droit à une pension alimentaire pour conjoint, compensatoire et non compensatoire, et ordonne des arriérés dès la séparation. Malgré la non-divulgation, il fixe le revenu de l’intimé selon la preuve (2019–2026) et accueille l’indexation annuelle et l’exécution par le Service des obligations familiales.
Juge B. Holowka

Lemieux v. Huggins (2026 ONSC 5634)
In a family law trial about parenting and support, the Court holds the mother’s move to Augusta is a change of residence, not a “relocation” under the CLRA, and permits it. The Court limits expanded overnights due to poor co-parenting, fixes child support and arrears, and stays s. 7 arrears pending CRA disability determinations.
Justice J. Audet

Civil Matters

AtkinsRéalis Construction (Pacific) Inc. v. Barton Malow Canada Ltd. (2026 ONSC 5896)
On a motion under the Arbitration Act, 1991, the court assumes jurisdiction to order an arbitrator’s explanation but declines to do so. It finds the remedy under s. 40(2) discretionary, weighs the applicant’s unexplained delay and arbitral finality, and notes the appeal court can require explanations under s. 45(4). The motion is dismissed.
Justice K. Jensen

Azzi v. Kelly (2026 ONSC 5774)
On a motion in a motor vehicle accident action, the Court appointed a litigation administrator for the deceased defendant’s estate to lift the automatic stay and let a scheduled jury trial proceed. It held that further adjournment would cause concrete prejudice, while the defence’s concerns were speculative and addressed by the appointment.
Justice A. Kaufman

Azzi v. Kelly (2026 ONSC 6045)
On a motion for leave to amend a statement of claim, the Court permits an increase in the damages claimed to match previously served expert reports. It finds no specific, non-compensable prejudice caused by the amendment, and rejects delay arguments because the defendant knew the claim could exceed policy limits. The motion is granted.
Justice A. Kaufman

Barton Malow Canada Ltd. v. AtkinsRéalis Construction (Pacific) Inc. (2026 ONSC 5903)
In an application to enforce arbitral awards, the court dismissed a claim for additional post-judgment interest on the HST component because the interest award was ambiguous. It held that, under s. 50 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, an enforcement judge may enforce only clear relief, not interpret or supplement the award.
Justice K. Jensen

Family Physiotherapy Centres Inc. v. MacQuarrie et al (2026 ONSC 5613)
In an action for solicitor negligence and breach of fiduciary duty arising from a share purchase, the Court finds the solicitor breached the standard of care and a fiduciary duty by not sharing a material retirement-home list. It awards $125,000 for overpayment, rejecting claimed losses tied to later OHIP changes.
Justice O. Rees

Gulzar v. Pioneer Mews Inc. et al (2026 ONSC 6049)
On a motion to strike or dismiss, the Court holds that absolute privilege for statements and documents in judicial proceedings extends to the lawyer’s client. The plaintiff’s tort and rights-based claims against the defendant arise from allegedly false evidence filed in prior litigation and are struck as frivolous, vexatious, and an abuse of process, with $3,000 costs awarded.
Justice A. Doyle

Piyau c. Lacassagne et al. (2026 ONSC 5641)
Dans une motion en radiation, le Tribunal conclut que la déclaration, bien qu’énonçant notamment négligence, rupture de contrat, diffamation et Charte, vise essentiellement à remettre en question des processus et décisions académiques protégés par la discrétion universitaire. Aucune cause d’action raisonnable n’est révélée; la déclaration est radioed sans autorisation de modification, avec dépens.
Juge A. Kaufman

Portelance c. 1343633 Ontario Inc. (2026 ONCS 5659)
Dans une motion avant procès portant sur des rapports d’experts, le Tribunal refuse de proroger les délais, faute d’explication raisonnable et vu le préjudice et le risque d’ajournement. Il autorise toutefois la modification de la déclaration pour ajouter une défenderesse, sous réserve de la prescription, puis ajourne le procès afin de permettre un avis juridique indépendant.
Juge M. Smith

Rona Inc. v. 11449346 Canada Inc. et al (2026 ONSC 5877)
On a motion for default judgment, the Court held a corporate director personally liable for unpaid construction materials under a personal guarantee and for breaches of the statutory trust under ss. 8 and 13 of the Construction Act. It granted declarations and judgment totalling $1,991,350 (inclusive of interest), plus substantial-indemnity costs.
Justice A. Doyle

Criminal Matters

His Majesty The King v. Gobin (2026 ONSC 5921)
On sentencing after a guilty plea, the judge imposed 5 years and 9 months (less 387 days’ pre-sentence custody credit) for discharging a restricted handgun with intent to wound or endanger life. After a Gardiner hearing, the Crown failed to prove he knew he was shooting at police, given extreme intoxication. Mental illness, rehabilitation, and harsh remand conditions reduced moral culpability and justified departing below the Bellissimo range.
Justice A. London-Weinstein

R. v. A.N. (2026 ONCJ 605)
In a youth sentencing decision following trial convictions, the Court holds that non-custodial options would not satisfy the YCJA given the gravity of fentanyl trafficking with a loaded handgun, rapid reoffending, and poor past compliance. It imposes an 18-month secure custody and community supervision order (with 1.5:1 credit) plus 12 months’ probation.
Justice A. Kortenaar Continue reading →

Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Abughoush v. Sharif (2026 ONSC 5535)
In a family law case conference, the court held it could make a contested temporary parenting order on proper notice in exceptional circumstances. Applying the Divorce Act best-interests factors, it ordered week-about parenting mainly in Ottawa, with a mid-week visit and permitted Ontario travel on notice, pending a relocation motion.
Associate Justice I. Kamal

Tomlinson-Wells v. Wells (2026 ONSC 5728)
In a family-law trial on corollary relief, the judge finds a 2009 transfer of the matrimonial home into one spouse’s name was not a gift and imposes a 50% resulting trust. The judge orders equalization (about $293,000), dismisses an unequal-division claim, sets occupation rent from November 1, 2024, and imputes income for child support.
Justice P. MacEachern

Civil Matters

Dutremble et al. v. Heartland Farm Mutual Inc. (2026 ONSC 5741)
On a summary judgment motion in an insurance coverage action arising from a house fire, the Court grants leave to amend to expressly plead punitive damages but dismisses summary judgment. Conflicting evidence on rebuilding costs, valuation date, causation and mitigation (including failure to invoke appraisal), and alleged bad faith requires a trial.
Justice A. Kaufman

Thompson et al v. Bourcier et al (2026 ONSC 5523)
In an estate application for reimbursement and trustee removal, the judge holds that an adult child failed to rebut the presumption of resulting trust for funds taken from a parent’s accounts and an insurance annuity. The judge orders repayment by deductions from her estate share, removes the respondent siblings as estate trustees, and dismisses a burial-plot claim.
Justice N. Somji

White v. Anderson et al. (2026 ONSC 5279)
On a motion for leave to amend a statement of claim to add two defendants and discontinue claims against others, the motion judge adjourns the motion. Despite the mandatory language of r. 26.01, the moving party must comply with service rules. Service on one proposed defendant was unsupported by evidence.
Justice S. Corthorn

Criminal Matters

R. v. Azouka Ayo (2026 ONSC 5410)
In a criminal prosecution for alleged child abuse, the trial judge disbelieves the accused and accepts key evidence that he assaulted one complainant on September 18, 2023. The judge convicts for assault, but acquits on assault with a weapon and uttering threats because the evidence was unreliable on scars and the French threat words were unknown.
Justice P. Roger

R. v. Mohamed (2026 ONSC 5406)
In reasons on a mid-trial ruling in a jury murder trial, the judge held there was an air of reality that gasoline vapours may have been accidentally ignited, based on the Crown expert’s evidence. The jury was therefore instructed it could return manslaughter, rather than murder, if it found the accused poured gasoline but did not ignite it.
Justice A. London-Weinstein

Divisional Court Decisions by Ottawa Judges or of Local Interest

J.S-R.v. Children’s Aid Society of Ottawa et al. (2026 ONSC 5568)
On a motion to quash an appeal in a child protection matter, the judge held there is no statutory right to appeal a final Openness order, no Divisional Court jurisdiction to revisit an Extended Society Care order already appealed, and no jurisdiction to appeal an Adoption order. The appeal was quashed and leave to amend dismissed, without costs.
Justice A. Doyle

LF v Director of the Ontario Disability Support Program (2026 ONSC 5660)
On an appeal and judicial review of an ODSP eligibility decision, the Court finds the Tribunal’s one-year medical review order under s. 5(1) unreasonable because it gave only hopeful, non-evidentiary reasons and did not assess the record using a “whole person” approach. The matter is remitted; no costs.
Justices W. Matheson, M. Gibson and, P.A. Schreck

McLeod v. Direct Coil Inc. (2026 ONSC 5369)
On judicial review, the Court finds the Tribunal unreasonably dismissed a human rights application under s. 45.1 of the Human Rights Code based on a WSIB decision. The WSIB expressly treated accommodation as outside its mandate, so it did not deal with the substance. The dismissal is quashed; no costs.
Justices W. Matheson, M. Gibson and, P.A. Schreck

Smith v. Quinte West Non-Profit Housing Corporation (2026 ONSC 5672)
On a motion to extend time to seek judicial review of an RGI rent determination, the Court refused an extension under s. 5(2) Judicial Review Procedure Act. The delay exceeded three years, prejudice was presumed and not displaced, and the proposed review lacked apparent merit and sought remedies beyond judicial review. The motion and application were dismissed.
Justice M. Labross

Court of Appeal Decisions of Local Interest

Centre de Services à l’emploi Prescott-Russell Inc. v. Forage M3 Drilling Services Inc. (2026 ONCA 692)
On appeal from summary judgment dismissing a third-party claim, the Court holds the motion judge wrongly read the loan and security documents in isolation. Interpreting the indemnity agreement as a whole and in context, it declares the sellers gave personal guarantees, rejects any liability of the family trust, and remits compliance with notice/defence conditions.
Justice P. Rouleau, J. Thorburn and, L. Favreau

Chamseddine v. Ghani (2026 ONCA 697)
In a family law appeal from trial orders on equalization, unequal division, support, and sale of a matrimonial home, the Court upheld findings of nondisclosure and adverse credibility. It affirmed unequal division under s. 5(6) of the Family Law Act, income imputation for child and spousal support, and rejection of a claimed vendor take-back mortgage.
Justices D. Paciocco, L. Sossin and L. Madsen

R. v. T.R. (2026 ONCA 723)
On an appeal from sexual assault convictions after a jury trial, the Court upheld evidentiary rulings excluding a post-incident sexualized conversation as myth-based and of no probative value, and refusing nurse’s notes for their truth due to unreliability. The appeal was dismissed.
Justice P. Lauwers, S. Gomery and, R. Pomerance

New Titles – October 2026

See the list below for all new materials now available at the CCLA library!

New in Print
Available for in-library use. Find the call number through the CCLA Catalogue or contact library staff for help.

New Electronic Resources
Available in-person through the CCLA Library Toolkit.

New CPD
Available remotely through LSO CPD Materials.

Recently Published Ottawa Decisions

Find below recently published Ottawa decisions, available for free through CanLII.org.

Family Matters

Abdollahpour v. Abdollahpour (2026 ONSC 5038)
In a post-trial family proceeding cost decision, the judge awards the successful spouse $65,000 in costs, citing the other spouse’s bad faith, unsubstantiated allegations, duplicative proceedings, and non-compliance with settlement minutes, which prolonged the case. The award is paid from the other spouse’s share of sale proceeds, with HST payment clarified.
Justice J. Audet

K.H. v. Children’s Aid Society of Ottawa (2026 ONSC 5031)
In a child protection status review proceeding, the judge grants summary judgment dismissing a biological father’s bid for full-time care. Applying the CYFSA best interests analysis, the judge finds the father’s plan unrealistic and unsupported, and prioritizes the child’s stability in kin care. The extended society care order is maintained, with child-held access to the father.
Justice J. Audet

K. N. v. L.K. (2026 ONSC 4771)
In post-trial family law proceedings on spousal support and costs, the judge finds a parenting-role change is a material change but does not end established entitlement. The judge orders time-limited, stepped-down support over seven years with specified amounts and awards $113,518.16 in costs, offsettable against support.
Justice K. Jensen

Leblanc v. Alford (2026 ONSC 5330)
On an urgent parenting motion, the judge interviewed the 12-year-old under s. 64(2) of the Children’s Law Reform Act and gave due weight to his clear, uncoached preference. Applying the best-interests factors in s. 24, the judge temporarily ordered primary residence with the father, joint decision-making with a consultation process, school registration, defined parenting time, and dismissed police enforcement.
Associate Justice I. Kamal

Lubanski v. Giernalczyk (2026 ONSC 5192)
In a family law case conference, the court held it could make temporary orders on proper notice. It ordered the Respondent to reimburse funds withdrawn from a joint account and to deliver vehicle registration and insurance, set quarterly corporate bank-statement production, refused to decide contested mortgage arrears at conference, and declined to set aside a prior costs order.
Associate Justice I. Kamal

Civil Matters

4269209 Canada Inc. v. Tuck-It Away Secure Storage Inc. (2026 ONSC 5094)
In an application under the Repair and Storage Liens Act concerning a proposed bulk sale of stored inventory, the court adjourns both sides’ requests because a Quebec BIA proposal proceeding may impose a stay under ss. 69 and 69.1. The parties must address notice, proposal status, and any required leave.
Justice C. MacLeod

Bradley-Kelly Construction Ltd. v. GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd. et al, (2026 ONSC 5180)
On a motion for summary judgment in a construction lien dispute, the Court held that work at two project sites formed a single “improvement” under the Construction Lien Act. With no evidence of multiple improvements and a common project purpose on contiguous lands, the lien was timely. Summary judgment was granted, the cross-motion dismissed, and the remaining holdback ordered released.
Justice K. Perron

Business Development Bank of Canada v. 13904903 Canada Inc. (2026 ONSC 5083)
On a summary judgment motion in a Simplified Procedure debt action on a loan and guarantees, the Court awarded outstanding principal and pre-judgment simple interest at the loan’s floating contractual rate under s. 130 of the Courts of Justice Act. It allowed post-judgment interest on principal at that rate, denied post-judgment interest on pre-judgment interest, dismissed “Other Amounts,” and fixed partial indemnity costs.
Justice S. Corthorn

Cleary v. The Corporation of the Municipality of Brighton (2026 ONSC 5212)
On an application for declarations invalidating municipal by-laws regulating short-term rentals and administrative monetary penalties, the Court held that the vires challenge is an application for judicial review within the Divisional Court’s exclusive jurisdiction under the JRPA. It transferred the vires and Charter issues together and invited costs submissions if needed.
Justice O. Rees

CMLS Financial Ltd. v. Ashcroft Development Inc. et al. (2026 ONSC 5101)
On a receivership application return, the Court declines to appoint a receiver because the vacant development lands are being marketed, the applicant’s debt has been significantly reduced, and a receiver could interfere with sales and increase costs. The application is adjourned to January 15, 2027, with costs reserved.
Justice C. MacLeod

National Bank Of Canada v. OCM Auto Financing Ltd. (2026 ONSC 5060)
On an application to appoint an interim receiver, the judge finds it necessary to protect the debtor’s estate and the secured creditor’s interests after defaults, missing collections held in trust, delayed disclosure of adverse developments, and questionable payments. The application is granted, but the interim receiver’s powers must be narrowly tailored and time-limited.
Justice K. Perron

Nepean Building Supplies v. Markelangelo’s Inc. (2026 ONSC 5195)
On a motion for default judgment for unpaid building materials, the Court validated service on a corporate defendant and allowed amendment of the plaintiff’s name. It granted judgment for $185,423.97 against the corporate debtor and personal guarantors, jointly and severally, but refused contractual 24% interest, awarding pre- and post-judgment interest under the Courts of Justice Act and partial-indemnity costs.
Justice S. Corthorn

Paradis et al v. 1000201315 Ontario Inc. et al (2026 ONSC 5272)
On a motion to discharge certificates of pending litigation, the Court found a triable issue that purchasers’ deposits could support a constructive trust over five improved blocks. Balancing the equities, it discharged the CPLs and ordered $618,000 from any sale proceeds paid into court as substitute security under s. 103(6) Courts of Justice Act.
Justice M. Sirivar Continue reading →

Introducing Reference LiNK: A New Way to Connect with Legal Research Support

We are happy to announce that LiRN just released a new live chat service called Reference LiNK. Through this service, you can instantly connect with experienced courthouse law library staff from across Ontario through the LiRN Network. Accessible by browser, email, or text message, it offers trusted resources and responsive research support. You can use it wherever you are and it is staffed Monday to Friday from 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM.

You can use it if you need reference and research assistance. The library staff on Reference LiNK can help with:

  • Finding legislation, cases, commentary, and other legal information resources.
  • Performing specific legal-research tasks like noting up citations, tracing legislative history, researching legislative intent, and providing useful precedents and forms.
  • Suggesting search strategies and research tools.
  • Locating library materials and publicly available legal information.
  • Referring you to additional resources and services that may be helpful.
  • Providing assistance with the access to and use of legal research products (such as Lexis+, Westlaw, and more).

Here’s a quick video that explains how it works: Introducing Reference LiNK: Your Courthouse Library, Online. If you have any question, feel free to contact them or check out their FAQ.

Reference LiNK is a collaborative service of courthouse libraries across Ontario, coordinated by the Legal Information and Resource Network (LiRN) and made possible through funding from The Law Foundation of Ontario.

New LibGuide: How to find an Order in Council

Did you know that we can help you track down historical documents? Whether they are reports, government documents, court decisions, or other materials, we have more than one trick up our sleeves.

To assist you with this type of research, we recently published a new research guide on how to find Orders in Council—whether at the federal or provincial level, or even if the order was never published. You’ll find all this information in the guide.

You can find the LibGuide under the Library tab on the CCLA website. Here’s a direct link to it: How to find an OIC.

New Titles – September 2026

See the list below for all new materials now available at the CCLA library!

New in Print
Available for in-library use. Find the call number through the CCLA Catalogue or contact library staff for help.

New Electronic Resources
Available in-person through the CCLA Library Toolkit.

New CPD
Available remotely through LSO CPD Materials.

Summary of our CanLII Webinar

If you have missed the last training session on CanLII or just want to have another look, here is a summary of what was said.

About CanLII 

CanLII stands for Canadian Legal Information Institute. It is a non-profit organization that started in 2001.  

  • It was funded in a joint effort by the Federation of Law Societies. 
  • In general, it is part of a larger free access to the law movement. This website is available to anyone with internet access, with no cost to the user at any point. 

In the top right corner, there is a drop-down box if you wish to change the language of the website, their interface is bilingual, but it will not change the language of the case or the legislation you are looking at. To do that you will have to change the language from the document you are viewing. It is a separate function because not all content is available in both languages. You also have the sign in button. You do not need an account to use CanLII. It is only if you wish to use their other functionalities, such as myCanLII and the CanLII AI tool. On the other side, the CanLII logo will bring you back to the homepage when you click on it.  

 

Primary law 

Under the search section, we have Primary law.  This section contains legislation and decisions from all over Canada. Here is the page for Ontario:

Ontario Primary Law

You can then use the search box at the top, and it will search things from Ontario only or you can browse through the list of databases. From here, you have access to legislation, Courts and Boards and Tribunals decisions from Ontario. The Federal page looks very similar.

 

Commentary 

Commentary refers to the secondary resources that CanLII has, meaning materials about the primary materials. That collection contains a few different types of commentary materials, so to get to the commentary, you can click on See all and then you can choose which type of document you want to browse, books, articles, reports, etc. It will then show you a list of the different publications or where the material is from. 

CanLII commentary section

I want to highlight three items under books. They can all be found under CanLII (Canadian Legal Information Institute). 

 

Searching

You have three options to begin your research. If you use the boxes from the main page, you are by default searching everything on CanLII – all federal and provincial legislation, cases, decisions, commentary, etc.

CanLII Search boxes

Document text 

The first one, “Document text”, is your keyword search. It is in this box that you will use your Boolean terms and keywords.  

For example, you can use this box when you do not know exactly the case you are looking for, you have larger question or you are looking for something on a specific topic. This box will not predict what you are typing. 

CanLII Search

The first tab says “All CanLII”. As you look along the rows, you can see where those are (cases, legislation and commentary). 

That first tab for all of CanLII – you can do an immediate sort right here by jurisdiction. Next to each jurisdiction is a number – that is how many results per jurisdiction.  

If you are doing this search to find case law, you want to move over to the next tab, which is the cases tab. There are four options, which you can see just below the tab – jurisdictions, court and tribunals, date, and subjects. 

For the first, jurisdiction. It is the same as the one we just saw. When you select a province, you will get the line at the top. It says “there are X decisions from the Supreme Court of Canada that match the search” – add them to your results. This means the results in general are just from the province you selected, which is what you want, but you might be missing some key upper court decisions. It will only ask for the Supreme Court, as it is the highest court. 

If you want to do some custom court level searching, this is where you use the next set of filters, All Courts and Tribunals. You will be able to select precisely which courts you want to see results from. The default is all courts and all tribunals. 

Next filter is date. The default, of course, is any date. You can make this more specific – with the preset options, last week, last three months, last year, last three years, last ten years, and then you can get into some specific date is and date range. 

The last filter is Subjects. These classifications are available as a filter, and are also displayed in the search results list (as bubbles). Note though that these are for court decisions only, not tribunals. 

Now if you were looking for legislation in your results, you would use the next tab over – legislation. First up, there is a similar jurisdiction filter, which will let you select the province, territory, or federal. 

CanLII legis

The second filter is the type of legislation, it will let you pick constitutional acts, statutes or regulations. You may see some options here that are not available for the jurisdiction you are working in. For example, historical revised statutes are not available for Ontario.  

The final filter is a version or date filter. CanLII does offer point-in-time versions of legislation – early 2000s is about as far back as you can go. You can enter a date there and they will bring you to the legislation available on that date. 

Under the last tab, commentary, you will see there are four ways to narrow. The first is subjects. The second is type. The third is publication year. 

CanLII comms

The fourth is sources. This gives you three options for some of the commentary on CanLII – titles from the CanLII authors program, the CanLII connects blogs, and “other sources” which are the non-CanLII authors in the commentary collection. Again, you can combine the filters, but you might find your results dropping rapidly. You can always modify your search from the same page, using the search boxes at the top.

A couple other things to note about the results screen. First off, where it says “By Relevance.” If you click on the down arrow, you can change the order in which your results are appearing. 

Next, you have the language option. If you want only French results, you can change it and it will show you only the documents available in French. You can note that it is less than in English, because not all of them have a translation. 

You then have the display options. There are two main options, the list and the list with a view of the document.

 

Case name, document title, file number, author or citation 

The second box is to find a specific document. For example, if you are looking for Canada v. Vavilov, you start writing and it will give you a list of related documents that you can scroll. You can then click on the document you were looking for, and it will bring you directly to it. CanLII uses a predictive text to suggest results.  

If you do not see it in the list, you can start typing and press enter or select the first line. It will then give you a normal list of results.  

You can also use that section to find other types of documents, such as legislation. And you will be taken directly to that piece of legislation, the most current version of the title you selected.  

CanLII documents

Noteup/Discussion 

The last box is the Noteup/Discussion box. It will allow you to see the documents that cite a specific case, piece of legislation or other type of document. You can also add specific paragraphs to your search. Same thing if you are looking into a certain Act, you can add one or more sections. That way, you can do a very custom search.  

One thing to point out is the “Or” section to the left. It lets you set up a search that searches for something citing Document A or Document B. You can change that to “And”. You can add more documents than that, but this is a great feature if you are trying to narrow down a lot of citing cases to something on a very specific point.  

CanLII Noteup

Documents

CanLii doc

Once you have selected a document, right at the very top here, we have the “Find in document” search bar. Here, you can enter a word or use quotation marks to look for a phrase, hit enter, and this word will be highlighted where it appears on the page. There are also arrows that can help you skip through the document to those appearances and you can also edit your search. 

Next thing is the link to toggle between languages. Because this case came from the Supreme Court, it is available in both English and French, so CanLII has both. If you click on it, it will switch to French, but your interface will still be in English. 

You also have at the top a PDF link. If you want to download the document or print it.  

Immediately underneath is the rest of the case information – date, alternate citations, and then the citation you could reference for finding this on CanLII, you also have a short permanent URL, I encourage you to use this one if you link the decision in a document or in an email. You will be sure that the link will be working long term. Beneath that: Most recent unfavorable mention. 

Next is the left sidebar. Clicking on any of those options will open up the information contained within the tab in the same screen as the document you are looking at. First up is History. It lists decisions related to this case. Sometimes a decision is missing or unavailable.

After that is Treatment. The documents that cite this decision specifically. Within this tab, there are three sub sections. The first subsection is everything that cites this decision, including commentary. This is a list of the most recent. The second tab is discussions, documents that discuss the document you are viewing. The jalapeno peppers are to indicate intensity. The highest ranking is five peppers. Blue peppers are discussion and yellow are unfavorable mentions. The third tab is just for the yellow peppers, so unfavorable mentions. You will not get a full list from these tabs; only 10 documents. To see all these documents, click on the Search for all discussing documents at the bottom. This will bring all the search results from the previous screen. You can now add keywords to your search or choose a paragraph. There is no further analysis applied to these results than the peppers. You can also filter results in the same way than showed before.  

Next, we have the Cited Documents. These are cases or legislation that are cited within this decision. If it is in blue, you can click on the hyperlinked words, and that will open that document in full. You can also see where it is cited within the decision. Clicking on the eye icon will prompt CanLII to highlight the instances of this piece of legislation within your document, and you can use the arrows in the top right corner to scroll through the decision.  

Next is CanLII connect. This will take you out of CanLII and to CanLII Connects, which is a site with related commentary or case summaries from the legal community.

Next is the AI Analysis. You like the name it is an analysis of the case provided by an AI tool. It includes the facts, history, legal issues, reasons and more. 

Last one is myCanLII, so if you have an account you can add the decision to your research folder or create an alert. 

We have looked at noting up the decision before from the tab on the left hand side, but you can also note-up from within the text of the decision. Looking at a document on CanLII you will find these bubbles with a pen on the right side. When you click on it you have different options. Copy text, copy the citation of this paragraph, copy link, change the language, alerts and finally the citing documents. When the bubble has a number, it tells you that this section has been quoted elsewhere. The blue on the side bar also highlights sections that have been quoted. The darker the blue, the more that section has been cited. You can click on the bar to navigate in the decision or if you hover over it, you will have a view of the paragraph.  

If you click on the “Citing Documents” link, you will be sent to the same search-results screen, but this time the results are showing just document that cite to that particular paragraph. 

 

Legislation 

CanLII legislation

For legislation, it is very similar. You have similar option at the top, like the language. You also have the blue bar on the right, it works the same. Immediately under the name and citation, we have additional information about this document. You have the currency of the legislation prominently displayed. You can also see the last date it was updated and from where just below that. There is also a permanent link.  

Moving over to the left-hand side, we have a series of tabs. The first here is the table of contents. When you click on this, we will again get a sidebar that pops out, that you can adjust, that has the table of contents for this document. Up at the top of this tab, you can also see a search box. It will search the content for what you put in there. 

Next is the versions tab. The default when you pull up this legislation from a basic search is the current version. You can click here on those blue hyperlinked date ranges to pull up the version of the legislation that was in effect in that specific date range. This will change what you are seeing on the right-hand side. You will note there is a warning at the top in red to indicate this is not the current version.  

If you want to compare two versions of the act, you need to select which versions you want to see the difference between. CanLII will go through and highlight differences. You can scroll through those differences using the arrow buttons at the top. You can also select other versions to compare from this page using the drop-down menu at the top.  

Next, is the Regulations tab. In force regulations are at the top, repealed, spent, or not in force are at the bottom. There is a filter bar, so you can enter a term here, but it is only looking for that term in the title of the regulation. 

Next tab is Amendments. This tracks amendments back to 2001 federally and in Ontario, but the coverage may be different for other jurisdictions. If you click on it, it will take you to the amending statute, the source law.  When you click on a document from this list, the tab that says “Amendments” in other legislation now says “amending” and list the legislation this amends.  

Finally, the last tab is Cited By. This is one of the ways that you can note up legislation. Just like with decisions, you will only get 10 results here. Click on Search for all citing documents to bring back all the citing documents for this legislation. The third box has the legislation we are looking at, and when you first click over here, it will be for any citation, any section. Again, you can add a section or more, and keywords. 

Another way to note up a section is to do that directly from the section you are interested in. You will see on the right hand side that there is a similar quotation bubble. You can click on that and get those same tools, but also a link to citing documents.  

 

CanLII Search+ 

CanLII Search+ is their new AI functionality. To use it, you will need to create an account, which is free.  

It does not work like most AI tools available on legal databases. It will not give you a direct answer or create new content for you, but will instead act as a research assistant, helping you create your search queries and analyze the results. It is not an AI tool that is going to hallucinate; it just maybe will not always give you the best results. It is great if you are not familiar with Boolean terms or if you are having difficulties formulating your queries. It can also be a faster way to find the decision you are looking for.  

CanLII Search+

Once you are logged into your account, you will find the tool on the right side of your screen. You just need to write your question in the first box and click on Search. 

You will find the query in the first search box of the top of the page, and sometimes it will use the filters. You can then browse the results yourself or you can click on Analyze, and the tool will rate the results out of five. After it is done analyzing, you will see the scores on the right. You might want to check the higher scored decisions first.   

The tool is free, but you have a limited amount of research and analysis per day (10 searches and 100 documents analyzed). 

Even though this tool does not think for you, you need to be careful when using it like any other AI product. Double check the results and do your own research. You can also use the query it gives you on other databases or modify it. Try different words or Boolean operators.  

That is it for the CanLII training, do not forget to check and register to our upcoming training sessions – Library Events